Table of Contents / Sample Articles

EAA 4:2, Fall 1999

...

Understanding the Geographies of China


China not only has the world’s largest population (over 1.3 billion), but it also is an extremely large country (more than 9.5 million square kilometers) with immense physical and cultural diversity. In fact, China should be viewed as an assemblage of pieces much like Europe.

shenzen.jpg (6603 bytes)
Cities emerge from rice paddies. View from the
I-Forum hotel near the railroad station, Shenzen

Anyone who tries to teach the geography of China faces the dilemma of either being very general (almost superficial) or delving into so many aspects and details as to be unable to complete the task in a single semester. How does one integrate three thousand years of history, language, local cultural practices, diets, architecture, et al. with basic physical geographies and economics that range from subsistence farming and herding to sophisticated electronics and computer industries, cities like Shanghai or Shenzhen?

To provide a sense of China’s diversity and its rich cultural fabric, one should probably divide the political unit into its natural parts, parts that are distinct both physically as well as culturally. Many of these "parts" have had a distinct cultural and political history as ancient kingdoms or states. Examples would include the ancient states of Shu and Ba in modern Sichuan, or of Nanzhao in modern Yunnan. In fact, each of the geographic regions discussed below at one time contained a distinct and separate culture, which over time have become melded into what is modern China. Still, these regions remain distinct in many respects.

But, one also should demonstrate the many ways in which China has been "united" and how many of its canals and rivers have been evolved and used to "unite" these many parts.


Some Useful Themes

Simply memorizing maps and map locations is not geography. Understanding the interaction between a natural environment and various human and cultural patterns is a major objective. These provide not only a "sense of place," but they illustrate how people adapt differently in different environments. China is not one large homogeneous mass of people and behaviors. To fully appreciate its geographic and cultural diversity, one needs to follow some general themes that can act as a kind of guideline. Among the more useful themes in teaching and understanding the diversity of China are:

  • Vernacular housing/shelter—how do people design their shelter to avoid climatic extremes and/or threats from invaders or neighbors?

  • Diets—What basic foods are available, and how do they reflect basic environmental conditions?

  • Economy—Given the natural environments, cultural preferences, and access to more distant markets, what kinds of economic activity other than self-sufficiency can evolve?

  • Cities—Cities in China have traditionally been centers of rule or control, not centers serving their economic hinterland. Thus, most cities have important strategic locations, and these should be "discovered" and discussed.

  • Regions—History and physical geography have often combined to generate distinct clusters of peoples and cultures. Often these have been "kingdoms" or "states" in the past.

sanmenxia.jpg (8134 bytes)
Sanmenxia pit house with fruit tree,
fourteen to sixteen feet deep

pithouse.jpg (9516 bytes)
Luoyang pit house


Regionally Distinctive Characteristics May Generate Regional, Cultural and Economic Identities

Everyone recognizes that any list of "typical" characteristics of a place will have many omissions and even overlaps with other places. Still, there are unique mixtures of foods, clothing, economics, etc. that give any region its own sense of place or flavor—a kind of cultural fingerprint—a method of distinguishing and understanding differences that are real, but often subtle. It is these distinctions that we seek to teach. It is important to understand that not all Chinese are alike or eat the same foods or talk the same way or even think the same. For example, some speak of the "Yellow River Valley" as a kind of uniform entity, despite its origins in the high Qinghai Plateau, passage through the arid loess plateau and gorges of Shaanxi, and finally across the open plains of North China. It is the recognition of geographic diversity that is an important objective and achievement when teaching about the geography of China.


The North China Plain

No geographic area so typifies the standard image or myth of China and the Chinese as the North China Plain. Here are found the people who form the image of stalwart farmers (peasants) living in closely packed villages and houses of mud or adobe, although today many of these traditional dwellings are being faced with fired brick.

nchina.gif (7653 bytes)

It is an area subject to the extreme heat and frequent droughts of summer or floods of spring. Life on the North China Plain is one of self-sufficiency and subsistence. And finally, the inhabitants of the plain have had to endure endless depredations by armies and bandits who swept across the area in search of food or other loot, but it is an environment of little surplus and no natural mineral or other wealth. It was a perfect environment for Christian missionaries, and later the Chinese Communists, to bring a message of hope to the often utterly destitute. Still, it also was referred to as the "good earth."

Mud-based, single-story houses
Wheelbarrows and canal boats for transport
Windy winters with dust
Wheat-based diets (especially steamed bread)
Many small villages
Winter food emphasizes potatoes


The Loess Plateau

loess.jpg (8007 bytes)
Ningxia, Loess, north of Guyan. Typical terraces and crop mixtures in the Loess Plateau.

While not as familiar to Westerners as North or South China, the Loess Plateau is an area of great historic importance to the Chinese. Most recently, it was the site of the headquarters of Mao Zedong and the Chinese Communist Party just prior to their conquest of China in 1948. In ancient times, this region was the meeting zone between the nomadic herders of the Mongolian and Central Asian steppe and the more settled farming communities of what would become China. It was on the margins of the loess areas that the great trading cities and capitals of empire first formed—Xi’an or Chang’an being the best known.

Because winters are harsh, water scarce, and trees even scarcer, traditional houses were caves cut into the friable loess. Today, some forty million people still live in underground (cave) housing. As with North China, it was an area in which poverty and banditry traditionally were endemic. Only the cities could become wealthy and then only via trade with areas outside the immediate region.

Cave houses or adobe construction
Highly eroded and gullied terrain
Wheat noodles and sour cabbage dominate the diet
Colorful paper-cut designs
Use of mules and horses in transport

loessplat.gif (9862 bytes)


The Sichuan Basin

Among the Chinese it often is said that "Sichuan is the first province to declare independence and the last to be reunited after there is peace." Nothing so well illustrates the ability of Sichuan to be wholly autarchical—self-sufficient from the rest of China—as this comment and its reality. In dramatic contrast to North China or the Loess region, Sichuan is a province and region that can produce virtually any product grown anyplace in China. It has sufficient surplus so that it has no need for imports of foods or even raw materials. It truly is a land of independence—and its politicians (including Deng Xiaoping) and warlords have often behaved that way. Its climate generally is mild, and its location provides access to every major economic and physical environment in China—Tibet, the Loess Plateau, the Yangzi Valley, and the Southeast uplands. What it lacks is easy and secure access to the sea—but then does it really need this?

dadu.jpg (6972 bytes)
Field and crop adjustments on the Sichuan-Tibet Frontier. Sichuan, Dadu River, Moxi xiang. River reclamation/debris flow reclamation.

sichuan.gif (14023 bytes)

An interior basin of vast variety in climates and foods—from tropical to cold mountains

A high living standard and densely populated

Houses cling to sloped land, leaving flat land for food production

Gateway to Tibet and mixed ethnic groups, especially in the Chengdu Plain

Teahouses for social gatherings and gossip reflect free time from agriculture


The Southeast Coast and Shanghai

g'zhou.jpg (7265 bytes)
Brick homes in Guangzhou,
southeast coastal area.

This region currently (1990s) is the area of the most active economic growth and development in China. It also was the region to first experience Western impact via the Opium War and "Treaty Ports." It is an area with historically the greatest number of Christian missionaries, Chinese Christians, and Christian churches. And, like so many distinct physical environments in China, it is dominated by ethnic peoples not fully identifiable as "Han" who speak distinct languages and who often have closer ties to Chinese overseas than to those in Beijing.

 

Ocean fishing and commerce

Ocean ports and trade

Seafoods and tropical fruits dominate diets

Teas are a regional specialty crop

Houses are of brick with elaborate tiled roofs, often with large gardens

Wealthy merchants construct massive public buildings, bridges, etc.

secoast.gif (10124 bytes)

 


The Yangzi (Changjiang Valley)

yangzivalley.gif (8517 bytes)

Separated from other regions by mountains and extensive wetlands, the Yangzi (Yangtze or Changjiang "long river"), its tributaries and lakes are the focus of life and economics. Fishing and commerce by boat dominate life and culture. Cities, such as Chongqing (in Sichuan province), Wuhan and Nanjing are dominated by economies tied to water-borne transportation and commerce—not agriculture or even food processing.

yangzi.jpg (7061 bytes)
Yangzi Valley—Three Gorges. Typical
adjustments to changing water levels

Major manufacturing centers exist along the river because of its cheap transport. There are large numbers of people who live their entire lives on small and medium-sized boats. They are "boat people" and make a living moving goods and people via the numerous lakes, canals and rivers of the entire Yangzi valley, especially in the areas around Shanghai. Contiguous to the river and dependent upon it for their cultures and economic well-being are the lake districts and provinces such as Hubei, Hunan, Jiangxi, Anhui, Jiangsu and Zhejiang.

Yangzi, Han, Xiang and Gan rivers
Chao Hu, Dongting and Poyang lakes
Rice and fish are dietary mainstays
Traditionally, people lived aboard boats
White plastered multistoried houses with black tiled roofs


Xinjiang

xinjiangmap.gif (15027 bytes)

Contrasted with eastern China, Xinjiang is a landscape of deserts, mountains, and oases. Located between the cultural empires of China in the east and Persia and Central Asia in the west, Xinjiang was an important historic link. One result of this intermediate position is that Xinjiang’s people are predominantly Moslem and Turkic in ethnicity and language. Because of their proximity to Persia, their agricultural history is more closely linked to the mercantile cities and trade of the ancient Silk Road than the irrigation practices of eastern China.

The trade and traffic along this famous route mixed people and cultures and introduced distinctive styles of music and musical instruments, especially the suona and pipa, or Chinese-style lute.

In the northern part of Xinjiang, the Junggar Basin, people have a long association with various Mongol peoples, and because this area has more moisture and grass than the Tarim Basin in the south, they are more pastoral than nomadic. The Tarim Basin was more closely related to Persia and the Islamic influences of the Middle East. It also was a traditional link (via the Silk Road) between Persia and the Middle East and eastern China. The Tarim Basin is characterized by city-dominated oases and mixed farming and animals (mostly sheep). In the Tian Shan (mountains that divide the two basins), the people are nomadic.

yurt.jpg (10515 bytes)
A Yurt and Kirghiz family outside
Pamirs, Xinjiang.

Earth/adobe houses
Central Asian or Persian-style architecture
Wheat noodles and flat, round wheat bread (nan) with mutton dominate the diet
Sheep, goats, camels and horses
Extensive areas of sand dunes
High alpine mountains
Common transport is by camel or long-distance bus and trucks


dunhuang.jpg (7317 bytes)
Resting caravan, Dunhuang.

camels2.jpg (6580 bytes)
Shadows of a camel caravan on the
sand dunes, Crescent Lake, Dunhuang.


Northeast (Manchuria)

As with Xinjiang and Tibet/Qinghai, Northeast China is one of the least typical environments compared to most of what is viewed as China in the popular mind. Winters are damp and cold. The best agricultural crops are commercial crops such as soybeans and sugar beets. Ice festivals mark winter holidays. Where the forests remain abundant, houses are built of wood and resemble housing in Russia’s Siberia.

nechina.gif (8428 bytes)

Regionally, diets are much richer in animal proteins and soybeans than in the rice and vegetables of central or southern China. Because of its rich coal and iron resources, the region was industrially developed by the Russians and Japanese, so it has more railroads and heavy industrial manufacturing than any other region in China. Perhaps a fitting analogy would be Germany’s Ruhr Valley or the Pittsburgh area of the U.S.

Industry and heavy manufacturing
Commercial agriculture (sugar beets, soybeans)
Railroads and superhighways for transportation
Russian-style architecture
Diets are dominated by meat and soybean curds


Tibet and Qinghai

tibet.gif (8188 bytes)

Best known as the home of the Dalai Lama and the Tibetan (Yellow Hat) form of Buddhism, the Tibetan and Qinghai plateaus are extremely high in elevation (an average of 4,000 meters (14,000 feet). They also have a very sparse population for an area of about 2 million square kilometers and a combined population of only 6.5 million. Most of these people are concentrated in only two or three cities. Other than in the more verdant areas of the south face of the Himalayas and the subtropical mountains along the Sichuan border, the region is dominated by vast expanses of flat terrain dotted with lakes—most of which are saline.

It is a harsh environment, not well suited to human use, and certainly not to crop agriculture. Typical shelters for the nomadic herders are felt tents during the summer and low mud and dung huts or rock shelters for the winter. The cities are dominated by monasteries and their unique inward slanting, extremely thick walls and small windows.

Diets are dominated by yak butter (for fat and vitamins) and toasted barley. There are few green vegetables, and meat is a staple. A major limit on food availability is the high altitude that allows water to boil at very low (non-cooking) temperatures. This makes cooking meat extremely difficult without some kind of pressure cooker.

Tibetan Buddhism and monasteries
Herding peoples (sheep and goats)
High altitude and cold, even in the summer
Clothing is woolen and sheepskin layered
People travel by horse or walk
Long-distance travel is by truck


Southwest Uplands

Southwest China is a landscape of dissected plateaus, dense forests, and great ethnic diversity. This is one of China’s most inaccessible regions and thus one of its more economically backward as well. The hilly terrain makes bicycle traffic almost impossible, and most people travel by foot, water or horse.

Hillsides were largely denuded during the Cultural Revolution (1966–76) but have been replanted—mostly with eucalyptus trees imported from Australia. In the south, near the border with Vietnam, are important tin mines originally developed commercially by the French. Plans for the 2000s are to develop close economic ties with Myanmar, Laos, and Thailand—a plan already well underway.

swuplands.gif (9041 bytes)

Diets are dominated by vegetables, rice, and ducks or geese
Houses may have thatched roofs and typically are built of wood or bamboo
Rolling hills, rugged valleys and mountains
Cormorant fishing from bamboo rafts
Thatched huts on stilts in the south
Rice, fish, fruits, and greens as diet mainstays
Multistory wood and stone houses in the north and west
Local transport is by foot, boat or horse
Tin mines are regional resources
Clothing is brightly colored, and silver jewelry is common

The linguistic and ethnic ties between these peoples, however, imply a future integration in the development of trade with Southeast Asia as well as growing economic independence of Beijing and North China.


Tying It All Together—From Empire to State

Clearly, to create political "China," it was and is important to tie these different "pieces" (regions) together. Transportation was, and remains, the most crucial factor. As the means of tying the country and its regions together proceeded, a common language and shared cultural values followed. Together they created an empire that was both political and cultural. Unlike the Roman Empire, the Chinese Empire evolved and has demonstrated an uninterrupted cultural and political history.


Imperial Highways

Because the origins of its empire lay in the interior of China—especially Xi’an—roads were initially more important than rivers and canals. Roads, of which the Silk Road is only one, but the best known to non-Chinese, not only followed the oases and core areas of historic China, they also clung to cliff faces by trestles when it was necessary to cross steep mountains such as the Daba and Qinling (e.g. the Shu Dao that linked the Wei valley with the Sichuan Basin).


The Grand Canal

Much earlier, but clearly of national importance by Song times (960–1279) Chinese engineers took advantage of natural lakes and waterways, as well as a major crustal fault in the wetlands between the Yangzi and the Huang Ho, and built a man-made canal linking the lower Yangzi Valley and Hangzhou. Its first "port" was Kaifeng (the Song capital) on the Yellow River; later it went to Beijing (the current national capital) in the far north.


Lakes and Rivers

Central China and the Yangzi River region are well served by the river as well as its major tributaries and their lakes. Thus, water and "boat people" are the dominant common tie and links for this region. As in the "three gorges" of the Yangzi and Daning rivers, where the river no longer was usable, there were trestle roads.

Clearly, every major region was united in part because of easy connections within its boundaries, but to create an empire or modern state transportation was, and remains, the key factor. Today, it is the railways and new highways that remain the physical manifestations of these "links." However, one cannot underestimate the importance of television and telephones as well as the airlines in keeping the Chinese viewing themselves as one people and culture. Their value in political control was demonstrated in 1989 when televised "wanted" posters were broadcast instantaneously across all China, and in June of 1997 when the return of Hong Kong became a national rallying point—again, across all of China and at the same time.


Political Organization

As important as physical means of transportation and communication in creating a common culture has been political organization. No empire or state can exist without both cooperation and means of enforcing order among such disparate geographic areas and peoples. This was the primary achievement of the first "emperor of China," Qin Shihuangdi, in 221 B.C.E. This first emperor defined the empire’s borders with Central Asia and established common laws for everyone in every geographic sector of the country.

In modern times, the reunification of China’s geographic regions (often historically independent kingdoms or "states") under a common Communist ideology was a major achievement of the Chinese Communists and the People’s Liberation Army.

Political organization in China has been successful in part because it recognizes the distinctiveness of various geographic areas. Today, large cities such as Shanghai, Beijing, Tianjin, Chongqing, and Hong Kong have special political status. Likewise, key economic cities have been created and given special political status to provide controlled access to modern economics and world trade. Finally, geographic areas dominated by non-Han Chinese cultures and peoples, such as Xinjiang, Ningxia, Tibet, Inner Mongolia, and Guangxi have been given political status (at least on paper) of being "Autonomous Regions." Even at the local level, it is common to find special status given to cities or even geographic areas that require some kind of special political status to maintain political peace and order—a kind of geopolitical "gerrymandering."

Thus, the Chinese have themselves long recognized their distinct geographic regions. It seems only reasonable that we should teach about China with the same awareness and sensitivity to geographic diversity.


References

NASA photographs taken from the Space Shuttles and the Russian Space Station can be viewed at the following websites: http://images.jsc.nasa.gov or http://shuttle.nasa.gov or http://ersaf.jsc.nasa.gov.

Vegetation Maps from AVHRR-NDVI

Maps with political boundaries, along with cloud-free mosaics of imagery from space can also be found on the "Map Machine Atlas" available on the National Geographic Society’s website: www.nationalgeographic.com.

Color satellite images related to China, along with discussions of their interpretations, can be found in various issues of the journal, GEOCARTO.

Articles and books that provide a sense of place and human/environment relationships would include:

Buxton, Leonard H. China: The Land and the People. New York: Gallery Books, W. H. Smith, Pub., 1988. A great collection of photographs and short descriptions of people and places.
Drege, Jean-Pierre and Emile Buhrer. The Silk Road Saga. New York: Facts on File, 1989.
Edmonds, Richard Louis. Patterns of China’s Lost Harmony. New York: Routledge, 1994.
Chiu, Huan-hsing and Zhongmin Lu. Folk Customs of China. Beijing: Foreign Languages Press, 1992.
Han-yuan Yao. The Grand Canal: An Odyssey. Beijing: Foreign Languages Press, 1987.
Hsieh Chiao-min and Jean Kan Hsieh. China: A Provincial Atlas. New York: Macmillan Publishing, U.S.A, 1995.
Knapp, Ronald G. The Chinese House. Hong Kong: Oxford University Press, 1990.
——. China’s Vernacular Architecture: House Form and Culture. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 1989.
——, ed. Chinese Landscapes. The Village as Place. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 1992.
McColl, Robert W. "House and Field in the Karakorams." FOCUS, vol. 37, no. 4 (American Geographical Society, 1987).
——. "By Their Dwellings Shall We Know Them—An Analysis of Housing Form and Function Among Inner Asians." FOCUS, vol. 39, no. 4 (1989).
——. "China’s Modern Silk Road." FOCUS, vol. 44, no. 2 (1991).
——. "Follow the Flowers: The Itinerant Bee Keepers of China." FOCUS, vol. 42, no. 1 (1992).
The Population and Economic Atlas of the People’s Republic of China. Compiled and edited by Population Census Office of the State Council of the People’s Republic of China and the Institute of Geography of the Chinese Academy of Sciences. Hong Kong: Oxford University Press, 1987.
Sivin, Nathan, ed. The Contemporary Atlas of China. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1988. Contains excellent regional maps showing topography and cities; lots of photographs define each region—provide a "sense of place."
Smith, Christopher J. China: People and Places in the Land of One Billion. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 1991.
Sun Yifu, ed. The Silk Road on Land and Sea. Beijing: China Pictorial, 1989.
Whitehouse, Patrick and Maggy. China by Rail. New York: Vendome Press, 1989.
Zhao Songqiao. Geography of China: Environment, Resources, Population and Development. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1994.


Useful Periodicals

China Pictorial
Bilingual Press
P.O. Box 388
Bendigo, VIC 3552, Australia
Phone: (03) 5443 3891; +61-3-5443 3891 (International)
Fax: (03) 5441 1600; +61-3-5441 1600 (International)

China Reconstructs
(Now known as China Today)
http://www.chinanews.org/ChinaToday/

China Daily
http://www.chinadaily.net/

Far Eastern Economic Review
Circulation Department
Citicorp Center 25/F
18 Whitfield Road
Causeway Bay, Hong Kong
Fax: 825-2503-1549
Send name and address by fax or mail for free trial copy.

Hong Kong Standard
4/F Sing Tao Building
1 Wang Kwong Road
Kowloon Bay, Hong Kong
Circulation : 852-2798-2777
Fax: 852-2750-5584

South China Morning Post
Subscriptions: Connie Chui
Phone: 852-2680-8680
Fax: 852-2680-8687
Reprints/Research
Phone: 852-2680-8100
Fax: 852-2665-6706


ROBERT W. MCCOLL is Professor and Chairman of the Department of Geography at the University of Kansas in Lawrence. He is an honorary member of the Institute of Geography, Mongolian Academy of Sciences and has done extensive fieldwork in both China and Mongolia. His current interests focus on the application of remote sensing and GIS to regional analysis in Inner Asia.